Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (2024)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

Crumbl Cookies are taking the country by storm! I am the source for copycat Crumbl cookies. With so many perfect Crumbl copycat recipes and way more to come,I am helping you bring Crumbl cookies to your very own kitchen.

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (1)

Copycat Crumbl Cookies You’ll Swoon Over

Crumbl has taken the country by storm the last few years, right? Everyone loves the giant cookies, unique flavors and comparing notes with friends. You know what everyone doesn’t love though? Missing out on your favorite flavor.. or even trying a cookie you can’t stop dreaming over only for it to never be featured again.

cue the tears

Lucky for you, I’ve reverse engineered a good number of their cookies, cracked the code so to speak, just to share the recipes with you. So we can all have our favorite flavors any time, anywhere. I know, I know. You’re welcome.

What are Crumbl Cookies?

Crumbl is an amazing cookie company that specializes in HUGE cookies in a variety of flavors. And with a rotating menu of different and incredible cookies, you can get new cookie flavors every week…and believe me, I want to! Plus, they deliver.Like, until midnight. Late night, warm cookie anyone?

If you don’t have a Crumbl near you, or if your crumbl addiction is starting to break the bank, I have the solution for you! These copycat cookies are just like the real thing, but so much more affordable.

Classic Flavors Crumbl Cookies Recipe

Crumbl has one or two flavors you can always find in the store despite their rotating menu. You can always find their famous Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie and a Sugar Cookie of some sort. Their Chilled Sugar Cookie with the Sweet Almond Icing that they are known for is usually available, but every once in a while a different variation of the sugar cookie will be featured. One like their Coconut Lime Sugar cookie, or Berries N’ Cream Sugar Cookie.

Crumbl Chocolate Chip Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (2)

A Crumbl chocolate chip cookie, in my opinion, is THE PERFECT chocolate chip cookie. An enormous cookie studded with big milk chocolate chips. It is thick and crisp on the outside, while still being chewy and perfect on the inside. This was Crumbl’s very first recipe and my copycat is absolute perfection!

Crumbl’s Chilled Sugar Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (3)

Crumbl sugar cookies are soft and buttery cookies topped with a perfectly sweet almond icing. The almond icing gives the cookie it’s signature flavor but it isn’t at all overpowering. So even almond extract haters still love this cookie! This cookie is always served chilled which gives the cookie such a chewy texture!

Specialty Flavors Copycat Crumbl Cookies Recipe

The brilliance of Crumbl’s business plan (aside from super delicious cookies) is their rotating menu of cookie flavors! You could go every single week and not repeat flavors. And believe me, I know people who do!

But the beauty of the rotating flavors is that they are every bit as good as the original flavors and sometimes even better. There are times where I am just waiting for my favorite flavors to circle back around! Thus my quest to bring perfect copycats to your kitchen! Never wait for your favorite flavor again! Just make them yourself!

Ultimate Peanut Butter

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (4)

A peanut butter cookie filled with warm, melty peanut butter, rolled in sugar and drizzled with even more peanut butter on top. The Ultimate Peanut Butter cookie for the ultimate peanut butter lover!

Crumbl Cosmic Brownie Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (5)

Cosmic Brownie Cookies are a super fudgey cookie topped with a thick fudge glaze and colored chocolate chips on top. This is a Crumbl Cookies copycat recipe that will change everything!

Snickerdoodle Cupcake Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (6)

This Crumbl copycat is just like the original! A cinnamon and sugar cookie topped with a vanilla cream cheese frosting with cinnamon sugar on top. These cookies are Snickerdoodle heaven!

Crumbl Chocolate Heath Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (7)

Chocolate Heath Cake Cookies are a fudgey chocolate cookie soaked with sweetened condensed milk, layered with a whipped cream frosting and sprinkled with Heath toffee bits.

Red Velvet White Chip Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (8)

Red Velvet White Chip Cookies from Crumbl are giant, gooey cookie with a rich red velvet flavor packed with white chocolate chips. This is a copycat version of Crumbl’s Cookie.

Cookies and Cream Milkshake Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (9)

Cookies and Cream Milkshake Cookies are a super sweet, rich, delicious cookie packed with Oreo flavor, topped with a cookies and cream frosting. A Crumbl Copycat!

Crumbl Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (10)

Decadent chocolate cookies filled with peanut butter chips. This classic combination of peanut butter and chocolate is sure to become a family favorite.

Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (11)

Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cookies are a giant graham cracker cookie with cheesecake frosting topped with a caramel drizzle and sea salt sprinkle.

Key Lime Pie Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (12)

Delicious graham cracker cookies, topped with a sweet and tart key lime topping, these Crumbl Copycats contain all the goodness of key lime pie in cookie form.

Crumbl Chocolate Oreo Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (13)

Chocolate Oreo Crumbl Cookies is a copycat recipe that are a super rich dark chocolate cookie base topped with a vanilla cream cheese frosting and garnished with Oreo crumbs.

S’mores Brownie Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (14)

This copycat Crumbl cookie is just like the original! This huge cookie is a mashup up of graham cracker flavored cookie and brownie topped with marshmallow fluff. S’mores Brownie Cookies are 3 of your favorite desserts in one!

Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (15)

Crumbl’s Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies are a Graham Cracker flavored Cookie base topped with a Cheesecake Frosting and a Raspberry Preserves Drizzle. This is my recipe, inspired by Crumbl’s Cookie.

Crumbl Birthday Cake Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (16)

A chewy and buttery cake batter cookie topped with a luscious cake batter cream cheese icing. This cookie makes everyday feel like a celebration.

Hazelnut Sea Salt Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (17)

This is a chewy Nutella-stuffed cookie topped with a melty Nutella drizzle and finished with a sprinkle of sea salt. This cookie is what Nutella dreams are made of!

Sea Salt Toffee

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (18)

This is a copy cat recipe of Crumbl’s Sea Salt Toffee Cookies which are a chewy original cookie base loaded with milk chocolate chips and buttery toffee bits topped off with a sprinkle of Sea Salt.

Buckeye Brownie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (19)

This is a Crumbl Copy Cat Recipe- an ultra rich brownie cookie with a peanut butter layer, all covered with melted semi sweet chocolate. This cookie is a chocolate peanut butter lovers dream!

Cookie Dough Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (20)

Cookie Dough Cookies are a cookie that taste JUST like cookie dough! Served chilled, it is a brown sugar cookie topped with a cookie dough icing and edible cookie dough bites. This is a Crumbl Copycat recipe at its finest.

Churro Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (21)

Churro Cookies are a cinnamon sugar cookie topped with a cinnamon buttercream, this Crumbl copycat is a churro lovers dream!

Waffle Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (22)

Crumbl’s Waffle Cookie is a warm brown sugar cookie topped with a dollop of Vanilla Buttercream and drizzled with maple syrup before eating. Breakfast in cookie form at it’s finest!

Chocolate Cupcake Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (23)

Crumbl’s Chocolate Cupcake cookie is a warm sugar cookie topped with the fudgiest chocolate icing ever.

Crumbl’s Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (24)

Crumbl inspired Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies are perfectly moist and delicious cookies studded with chocolate chips.

Molten Lava Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (25)

Chewy, chocolatey cookies filled with a warm gooey center. These cookies are so decadent and fudgy, they are a chocolate lovers delight!

Churro Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (26)

Churro Cookies are a cinnamon sugar cookie topped with a cinnamon buttercream, this Crumbl copycat is a churro lovers dream!

Pink Velvet Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (27)

Soft, chewy and delightfully pink, topped with a rich cream cheese frosting, these cookies taste even better than they look.

Twix Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (28)

Crumbl Twix Cookies are a sugar cookie base loaded with Twix bars, topped with caramel and milk chocolate. This Crumbl Copycat recipe tastes just like the real thing!

Aggie Blue Mint Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (29)

Crumbl’s Aggie Blue Mint cookies are minty chocolate Oreo perfection! With my perfected Crumbl cookie copycat recipes it is easier than ever to make Crumbl cookies in your very own kitchen!

Pecan Pie Crumbl Cookie

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (30)

Pecan pie cookies are the best pecan pie you will ever have, but in cookie form! A crisp tender cookie filled with caramel nutty goodness, this is the perfect cookie for the holidays!

Buttermilk Pancake Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (31)

This is a copycat recipe of Crumbl’s Buttermilk Pancake Cookie- There is actual pancake mix inside of the cookie and it’s topped with a buttermilk syrup glaze and a dollop of Vanilla Buttercream.

York Peppermint Patty Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (32)

A rich chocolate cookie, stuffed with a gooey mint cream and topped with more chocolate! These cookies are packed with all the flavor of a York Peppermint Patty, but with all the texture of a chewy cookie. Cookies don’t get much better than this.

Turtle Cookies

Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (33)

The most decadent, chewy chocolate cookie, smothered in caramel and chocolate and sprinkled with extra pecans. These Copycat Crumbl Turtle cookies are next level and absolutely amazing!

My Favorite Crumbl Cookie Recipes

Personally, my favorite crumbl cookie recipes are all of the cheesecake ones. Particularly that Raspberry Cheesecake cookie. It might be because it was the very first Crumbl Cookie I’d ever had, so it’s a bit nostalgic, or it might be that graham cracker base cookie. I’m literally drooling as I type this.

Another copycat recipe I can’t stop making is the Cookie Dough Cookie. I am a huge cookie dough lover (only the edible, egg-free kind though) and this cookie just hits the mark. From the actual cookie base to the cookie dough flavored frosting, the entire thing tastes like a giant piece of cookie dough.

Same-Dough Crumble Cookie Recipe

Something interesting that most people don’t realize is that a lot of Crumbl’s Cookie recipes can be boiled down to one of 4 base recipes. Sugar base, original base (think chocolate chip cookie), chocolate base and peanut butter base. Yes, they will occasionally have cookies that veer away from this, but a lot of their cookies are just little tweaks and variations of base recipes. In fact, I have a whole cookbook talking about and teaching exactly how to tweak base cookie recipes!

Crumbl Copycat Recipe FAQ

Where did Crumbl start?

From its humble beginnings in Logan, Utah, a College town. Crumbl has exploded across the nation and now has over 200 locations in 32 states and is considered the fastest growing cookie company in the world. And all of this in just 4 years!

How are Crumbl Cookies made?

While the exact process is unknown, my recipes provide a very convincing, if not spot on copycat. But walking into the store and seeing the size of their mixers, one thing is certain, they make them in BULK!

Are Crumbl Cookies worth it?

That might strike you as a funny question, but it is shocking to see how frequently that very question is googled!

Crumbl’s signature pink box contains 4 huge cookies and will run you about 10 dollars. So they aren’t cheap, but they aren’t so expensive that they are worth it if you need a quick cookie fix.

But for those of you who, like me, LOVE cookies, Crumbl was making a major hit to my pocketbook. Which is why these Crumbl copycats are so amazing! All the incredible flavors of Crumbl from your very own kitchen. And at a fraction of the price!

Are Crumbl cookies made from scratch?

Yes, each cookie dough is made in house using everyday ingredients in their open concept kitchen and then baked fresh right before serving.

What are the most popular Crumbl cookie flavors?

Chocolate chip, Chilled sugar, Chocolate Oreo, Cornbread, Waffle, raspberry cheesecake, Aggie blue mint, chocolate cake and Reeses cup.

More Recipes You Will Love

  • Chocolate Chip Banana Muffins
  • Chicken Fried Rice Recipe
  • Sugar Cookie Frosting
  • Easy French Bread Recipe
  • Scotcheroos
Crumbl Cookie Copycat Recipes - Cooking With Karli (2024)

FAQs

Does Crumbl under cook their cookies? ›

Our cookies are meant to be crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside but not undercooked. If your cookies seem undercooked, please contact Customer Assist using the chat bubble 💬 at crumblcookies.com/contact. We want to make a report with your feedback!

What brand of chocolate chips does Crumbl use? ›

Guittard Baking Chips: Crumbl uses the big milk chocolate chips in their famous Crumbl chocolate chip cookie recipe. To get the same result, you'll want to use the big milk chocolate chips too. However, feel free to use whatever chocolate chips you prefer.

Does Crumbl really use Betty Crocker? ›

However, a representative for Crumbl Cookies told the Daily Dot in a statement that it uses cake mixes “from time to time” in order to enhance the flavor and texture of our cookies.” The statement called the practice “consistent with other brands in the food & beverage industry.”

Does Crumbl use edible cookie dough? ›

Cookie Dough Cookies are a cookie that taste JUST like cookie dough! Served chilled, it is a brown sugar cookie topped with a cookie dough icing and edible cookie dough bites.

Why not to eat Crumbl cookies? ›

The consumer advocacy group wrote that a chocolate chip cookie from Crumbl has a full day's worth of saturated fat and more than half a day's worth of added sugar. For customers worried about eating too many calories in one sitting, Crumbl sells a cookie cutter for $8 that evenly divides its cookies into four servings.

How long are Crumbl cookies cooked for? ›

Bake Crumbl cookies in the oven for 5 minutes at 350° F (177° C). While your oven preheats to 350° F (177° C), line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Scrape off the frosting and decorations on top of the cookies and set them aside. Then, arrange the cookies on the sheet and bake them for 5 minutes.

Who is Crumbl cookies biggest competitor? ›

Crumbl Cookies's top competitors include Love&Cookies, Tiff's Treats, and Fancypants Baking Co.. Love&Cookies operates as a gourmet cookie company. The company offers a variety of gourmet cookies and frozen cookie dough, which can be baked at home. Its products are…

How do Crumbl cookies stay soft? ›

To keep your Crumbl cookies at their peak, transfer them to an airtight container as soon as possible after purchase or making. This helps prevent moisture loss and ensures that each bite remains as delightful as the first.

What makes Crumbl cookies so special? ›

The company's unique flavors and constantly changing menu may contribute to its success, since it's created a set of reviewers who anxiously await for the new menu to debut so they can try them. Crumbl has something of a cult following. Its signature pink boxes flow with the chain's Instagrammable aesthetic.

Are Crumbl cookies baked fresh daily? ›

About Crumbl Salt Lake City

Our cookies are made fresh every day and the weekly rotating menu delivers unique cookie flavors you won't find anywhere else. Follow us on social media or subscribe to our email list to get notified of our new flavors each week.

Why is Crumbl cookie suing dirty dough? ›

Crumbl Cookies filed a suit in May 2022 against Dirty Dough. The suit alleged that Dirty Dough infringed on Crumbl Cookies, producing products “similar to Crumbl's in both expression and look and feel.” The suit also called out Dirty Dough's packaging as “confusingly similar to Crumbl's packaging.”

What is Crumbl cookies most famous cookie? ›

One of the most popular Crumbl cookie flavors you can get is birthday cake. Of course it tastes just like good old-fashioned vanilla birthday cake. This cookie features cream cheese frosting and sprinkles.

How does Crumbl sell their cookies? ›

Whether you need dessert delivery*, curbside pickup, or something else, we make it easy to order cookies online and through the app.

Are underbaked cookies safe to eat? ›

What happens if you eat slightly undercooked cookies? Undercooked cookies are still edible, don't toss them! Some people prefer chocolate chip cookies underdone, but you can't know for sure that the egg has fully cooked (although that wouldn't bother me one bit unless the source was shaky).

Are Crumbl cookies baked daily? ›

Our cookies are made fresh every day and the weekly rotating menu delivers unique cookie flavors you won't find anywhere else. Follow us on social media or subscribe to our email list to get notified of our new flavors each week.

Is Crumbl doing well? ›

Now, Crumbl Cookies has more than 980 stores across the U.S., topping $1 billion in sales across all franchises while selling more than 300 million cookies in 2022, according to co-founders Jason McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley.

Do Crumbl cookies get stale? ›

Generally, Crumbl cookies maintain their quality for up to a week when stored properly at room temperature. However, refrigerating them may affect their texture and flavor, so it's best to consume them within a few days for the ultimate indulgence.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aron Pacocha

Last Updated:

Views: 5744

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aron Pacocha

Birthday: 1999-08-12

Address: 3808 Moen Corner, Gorczanyport, FL 67364-2074

Phone: +393457723392

Job: Retail Consultant

Hobby: Jewelry making, Cooking, Gaming, Reading, Juggling, Cabaret, Origami

Introduction: My name is Aron Pacocha, I am a happy, tasty, innocent, proud, talented, courageous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.